We called ahead and were told we did not need reservations. We told them the number in our party and when we'd be there anyway. After my family drove to Scottdale from Pittsburgh, Unity, and New Stanton, we were told they had no table for us. We explained that we had called ahead and were told 'they aren't any tables, I don't know what to tell you. '. Absolutely horrible customer service, rude, and unkind. Turned away my 85 yr old grandmother and family as we were going to celebrate an early Mother's Day. But, as I was searching for sites with reviews for Miss Marthas I came across city data with 5 health code violations for Miss Marthas, so now I'm glad we weren't able to eat there.
I am very sorry about your experience at Miss Martha's. The day before Mother's Day is one of our busiest of the year, so we always recommend reservations. We have taken your comments to heart and recently changed management. I hope that you will be willing to dine with us again!