We were excited to try out Reynolds Tavern, but we were very disappointed. The tea selection was ok. The rooms were nice, although they left the front door open so you could hear the busy traffic and people talking on the sidewalk. Service was terrible - our waiter (he appeared to be a local high school kid) spilled tea over our paper napkins (a separate issue) and never replaced them, and that was just the beginning. The finger sandwiches were unimaginative and looked old. The salad was not fresh (the lettuce was slimy). All that for nearly $60. We won't be returning.