I chose McCharles House for my Sister Day after reading all the reviews. None of us had been there before. It was a risk, but well worth it. The food was fabulous. Even my picky older sister loved it. The price was a little more than expected at $39, but after tasting the food all of us would pay this amount again. I wish there were a few more traditional tea sandwiches, but the additional dishes were worth the substitution. Also, we were only served one kind of tea; I didn't ask if there were options. Keep in mind that the menu is seasonal, so you will not necessarily get the same experience. If you don't appreciate good food and don't want to try something new, don't bother going. If you are an adventurous person who loves the Food Network, definitely try McCharles out.